Dining Out

Taste These Hidden Gems in the Pee Dee Region

While reading Taste the State: South Carolina’s Signature Foods, Recipes & Their Stories, in which authors chef Kevin Mitchell and Dr. David S. Shields, the hosts of PBS’s The Savers of Flavor, share their deep understanding of how South Carolina’s food is rooted in its land, culture, and customs, I was inspired to take a road trip into the Pee Dee region to experience the meat-and-three, soul-food culture for which the area is renowned.

Exterior Scott's Q
Scott’s Bar-B-Que

Studying an old-fashioned map of the rural landscape, its small towns webbed together by long stretches of backroads, I realized this was not going to be an easy adventure to plan: The Pee Dee region, located in the northeastern part of the state, spans approximately 6,500 square miles and encompasses 12 counties that border the Great Pee Dee River watershed. Traversing this vast swath of mileage wasn’t the only challenge—most of the area’s soul food diners don’t have an online presence, so it was difficult to figure out which restaurants to visit along the way.

After speaking to a couple of local friends who shared their pro tips, my teenage daughter and I successfully charted a course. Our goal was to check out hidden gems that are off the beaten path, discover their secrets, and create a comprehensive itinerary for hungry travelers. Appropriately, our first stop was the legendary Scott’s Bar-B-Que in Hemingway. Known since the early 1970s for its whole hog slow-smoked barbecue with a swoonworthy vinegar-and-pepper sauce, the side-of-the-road, cash-only establishment serves plates and platters that come with sliced white bread and a choice of sides that include coleslaw, potato salad, and baked beans. Seating is at outdoor picnic tables under a portico. Our recommendations: Come hungry and bring a cooler to take leftovers and extras home for later.

From Scott’s, we drove 45 minutes west toward Kingstree, past remnants of old tobacco and cotton plantations. Our destination was Connie’s Bakery, opened by wedding cake designer Connie Dozier in 2006. Famous for its sweets and pastries such as the fan-favorite peach cobbler pound cake, corn muffins, and cinnamon rolls that sold out before we arrived at lunchtime, the takeaway café also offers chicken and waffles, wings and fries, a mac-and-cheese chicken bowl, a variety of sandwiches including grilled cheese and a BLT, hot dogs, and soups such as broccoli and cheese or clam chowder.

Our next stop was Lavelle’s Diner, located on the outskirts of Lake City, about a half an hour from Kingstree, where 40 years ago Mildred Montgomery, the locally awarded South Carolina Queen of Country Cooking, opened the diner. Renowned for its buffet-style comfort food such as beef stew, fried chicken, Mac and cheese, okra, pigs’ feet, and collard greens, Lavelle’s sells out of crispy jowls early each morning. The peach cobbler goes quickly as well—sadly, there was none left by the time we arrived.

Baskets of Grapes Credit Matthew's Fruit Stand
Matthews Fruit Stand

Our route led us north into Lake City, a historic railway town brimming with Southern hospitality. There, we visited Ward’s Fish Market, a fresh-catch diner that’s been in business for seven decades. Of the variety of species to cook at home or that they prepare for dining in, Ward’s bestsellers are croaker and garlic shrimp with rice or hushpuppies, according to Robin Dennis, who’s been the owner for 24 years. She added that all of Ward’s fish, with the exception of locally sourced catfish, are saltwater varieties that come from Georgetown, and their oysters are brought in from McClellanville.

Next door to Ward’s, we were delighted to find Matthews Fruit Stand, which has served the community for about 20 years, according to the owners’ 6-year-old daughter, who greeted us when we arrived. She added that the produce is sourced from as many local farmers as possible.

From Lake City, we drove another 45 minutes to Florence where we checked into the Hotel Florence and dropped our bags in a spacious suite before walking across the street to Town Hall for dinner. Their farm-driven, seasonal menu takes country cooking to the next level: grilled shrimp skewers in an Eastern Carolina barbecue glaze, served with creamy coleslaw, a collard green salad with rainbow carrots, golden raisins, and a country ham vinaigrette; buttermilk- fried quail alongside yellow corn grits; and roasted half chicken in a blueberry barbecue sauce with butter beans and bacon. I recommend pairing with a pour from their extensive wine list, and enjoying at the rooftop bar.

The following morning, our 45-minute drive took us past churches, graveyards, and wide-open fields dotted with horses, cows, haystacks, and broken-down machinery into Marion, where we enjoyed breakfast at City Food & Spirits. Family-owned by Jean and Joe Abrams since 2014, the buffet-style diner also serves lunch and Sunday dinner, with choices such as back bones and rice, hog maw, barbecue pig feet, and grilled pork chops, string beans, turnips, cabbage, strawberry shortcake, and banana pudding.

On our way home later that afternoon, we passed food and hospital deserts peppered with trailer homes, farms, and an abundance of abandoned factories and dilapidated houses—stark reminders of the fact that these areas were “once populated by workers who had left in search of jobs when big corporations folded in times of economic hardship,” according to Brittany Abrams, the daughter who runs the front of house at City Food.

What’s held the small communities together over decades of difficulty, said Michae Lavelle McKenzie, who has taken over the business of Lavelle’s for her mother, is a secret ingredient that’s been handed down for generations: love. Tasting that is what made all the difference in a deliciously memorable road trip that would make chef Mitchell and Dr. Shields proud.

Partnered

Discover the Unique Flavors of South Carolina Cuisine

South Carolina cuisine highlights farm-to-table practices, tradition, and culinary trends, often courtesy of the state’s chef ambassadors.

Roots

Meet a South Carolina Local: Chris Williams

South Carolina native and 2022 South Carolina Chef Ambassador Chris Williams talked food, culture, and community with The Local Palate.

On the Road

Road Trip From Charleston to Columbia

Most people knock out the drive from Charleston to Columbia in 2 hours. But if there’s no rush, why not make a day and a road trip out of it?

trending content

More From Dining Out

Leave a Reply

Be the first to comment.