5 of the Best Po’Boys to Try in the Bayou State

Perhaps no sandwich is more authentic to New Orleans than the po’boy. It was created in the city in 1929: Michael Mizell-Nelson, PhD, a local historian, spent 12 years researching the sandwich and documented its origins as a “poor boy,” so named by Benny and Clovis Martin of Martin Brothers French Market Restaurant and Coffee Stand in solidarity with striking transit workers. With John Gendusa Bakery, still in operation today, the brothers developed a 40-inch loaf of French bread to minimize costs, and the poor boy was “generously filled with whatever one desired, from roast beef to oysters,” according to a 1933 New Orleans States article.

The po’boy is usually filled with ingredients local to and iconic of the state of Louisiana, from hot links to Gulf shrimp and oysters to crawfish. A loaf of locally made French bread is essential: crusty on the outside to keep the sandwich from getting soggy, and soft on the inside to absorb the flavors of whatever the po’boy is “dressed” with, from the traditional lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and pickles to hot sauce, gravy, or remoulade.

We started with a classic spot to get New Orleans’ most iconic sandwich, and then asked Louisiana native and chef Chris Borges for his favorite po’boys around the state, but with an added challenge: They have to be worth leaving The Big Easy to taste and enjoy. Here are our picks.

Mahoney’s

New Orleans

With its Magazine Street location in the heart of the French Quarter, this local institution offers not only wild-caught popcorn Gulf shrimp marinated in Crystal hot sauce and fried in a cornmeal-dredge mix but also the Po-Boy Fest winner The Peacemaker, with fried jumbo Gulf shrimp and oysters, cheddar cheese, and candied bacon. They serve their po’boys on Leidenheimer French bread.

Crazy ‘Bout Crawfish

Breaux Bridge

Fifteen minutes from the Crawfish Capital of the World, you can get swamp fried crawfish boulettes, crawfish jalapeño cheese cornbread, fried crawfish tails, and of course, boiled crawfish. But don’t miss the po’boy, which gets rave reviews from Borges: “Their free-fried crawfish po’boy is to die for. Why? It’s a whole po’boy of fried crawfish! Nuff said!” (Though it’s worth mentioning that the restaurant itself agrees: The menu tagline says this po’boy is “so good you gonna wanna slap someone.”)

Suire’s Grocery & Restaurant

Kaplan

Located in Vermillion Parish, known as “The Most Cajun Place on Earth,” Suire’s Grocery has attracted the notice of chefs from Anthony Bourdain (who visited in 2018) to Bryan Roof of America’s Test Kitchen. It’s a second-generation family-run “country cooking” spot, a great place to get gumbo, shrimp étouffée, and pistolette—but also, Borges says, a hot link po’boy. “[It’s] a heart-stopper—a decadent, guilty pleasure. I always make a stop there when I am in that neck of the woods.” 

Old Tyme Grocery

Lafayette

Louisianians and tourists from all over travel to eat at this long-standing spot, which refers to its sandwiches the old-school way as “poor boys.” You won’t find any frills, but you won’t need them; according to Borges, “Their fried oyster po’boy is no different than any other in composition, but the person who fries takes special pride in frying their oysters. Perfect dredge every time, fried to the perfect doneness, they select the perfect size for frying. Just a perfectly executed po’boy.”

Jed’s Local

Baton Rouge

Husband-and-wife team Russell (above) and Sally Davis relocated to Baton Rouge and opened JED’s after careers in hospitality with Commander’s Palace and Saltwater Grill. On their menu of “high-quality scratch cooking” is a host of freshly executed and reimagined Southern favorites, like the shrimp and fried green tomato po’boy with grilled Gulf shrimp, remoulade, lettuce, and a hard-boiled egg. “It’s delightful and delicious,” Borges says. 

keep reading

On the Road

5 Styles of Crabcakes To Try Across the South

Making crabcakes is a labor-intensive process, and it’s done wildly different all across the […]

Dining Out

The Ultimate Louisiana Dining Guide 2026

Our editors tackled the vast Louisiana food scene to find the best chef, best […]

Radar

15 Essential Southern Oyster Bars

These top oyster bars are lifting up and celebrating the Southern farm-raised oyster from […]